Why macho leadership has to go

“ We will tell you what we have decided when we have decided. You won’t like it, you won’t agree with it but we will be doing it any way because the financial situation demands it.”

”As we are all aware the organisation is facing some difficult financial challenges. To tackle these challenges we need to improve efficiency and make significant savings. Management will shortly be sitting down with your TU reps to discuss the way forward.

Despite  any rumours  you may hear no decisions have yet been made and management is committed to consulting on the detail of any proposals once they are clear “ Chief  Executive

Management claimed their email was to provide reassurance and squash rumours but this type of communication  is guaranteed to raise anxiety about pay and job security. May be that was management’s intension,  make people think a set of harsh, drastic changes which threaten people’s jobs are about to be introduced so that when the details are announced they are not as bad as people feared and the response is more relief than anger!

It’s a well established tactic but it not a good industrial relations strategy because the lack of transparency, and use of fear will destroy any trust and goodwill. Management may get there way in the short term but  find that passive resistance low morale and high turnover undermines the anticipated gains which as a result are  never fully realised.

Far better to announce a consultation process with employees and their representatives. Management briefings and staff road shows to share proposals and options being considered with sufficient detail so as employees know who would be effected and how. With clear time scales.
Maybe something like this would be better received.
I though I would write to all employees to share with you the financial challenges we are facing and seek your views and support on how best to meet them. I have asked your managers to come up with ways of saving money and I want to share these with you and your  TU reps to see how together we could make them work or alternatively come up with other solutions. Chief Executive 
 
No doubt , given the opportunity , the HR and communications teams could come up with something reflecting a spirit of transparency and meaningful consultation as well as the necessary realism.

Read more

Latest News

Read More

Understanding the risks associated with the gig economy

6 October 2025

Employee Engagement

6 October 2025

Gen Z is gaining a reputation for being the hardest generation to engage at work

Despite approximately 4.3 million Gen Z individuals (aged 16–24) being employed in the UK, making them the third-largest age demographic in the nation’s labour force,...

Employee Benefits & Reward

2 October 2025

Navigating the benefits maze

Discover how personalised employee benefits, AI-driven HR technology and smarter communication strategies boost wellbeing, engagement and retention....

Newsletter

Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

Latest HR Jobs

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE