John Terry case – is football a law unto itself?

John Terry case – is football a law unto itself?

A leading employment legal expert believes that the ongoing and high profile racism case involving John Terry highlights how football can often operate very differently from the rest of society when it comes to dealing with issues of race discrimination in the workplace.

Speaking on the same day as John Terry starts his FA hearing at Wembley over his part in an incident last October involving Anton Ferdinand, Tom Flanagan, Partner and Head of Employment at national law firm Irwin Mitchell, says the way in which some football clubs deal with this type of situation contrasts sharply with what most organisations would do when dealing with an employee accused of a similar act. Tom said:”Football sometimes appears to cocoon itself from the ‘real world’. This is a case of a senior employee allegedly racially abusing an employee of another business at that employee’s place of work in a high profile and public setting. “He appears to accept that he made the remarks and is putting up a technical defence to the specific criminal charge which he is entitled to do. Whilst the FA’s rules and regulations can complicate the situation, the club, as the employer, should still conduct its own investigation and reach its own conclusions about its employee’s conduct as an employee, regardless of the outcome of the criminal trial.

“It would not be unusual for an employee in John Terry’s position to be suspended pending the outcome of the investigation. He could also be, disciplined and even dismissed, perhaps for bringing his employer into disrepute, whether or not he was guilty of the criminal charge and even if that case has not yet been heard.” Mr Flanagan added: “The point being made that John Terry has been tried and acquitted already is misconceived. The criminal charge was that he created a public disorder which was racially aggravated. He was found not guilty of that particular charge. That was not a finding that he did not racially abuse Ferdinand nor was it even a finding that he did not make racist remarks. In fact he admitted making them and produced a sufficient defence to avoid being convicted of that narrow charge.

“He is a high profile figure in his club, the England set up and football as a whole and this is a high profile issue in a sport publicly committed to the “Respect” campaign to eliminate racism from football. Even given the finding of the criminal court, it is still possible that John Terry could face sanctions at club and trade / professional association (FA) level, in the same way as any other employee in his situation, in the rest of society.”

Drawing a comparison with other high profile professions, Tom added: “If one wanted to look for a parallel, it could be found in a high value senior employee where the employer is reluctant to investigate or discipline because of the perceived cost to the business of removing that employee. If an employer, such as an investment bank, acted in that way, it is likely to attract both public and legal criticism. Why should football be any different?”

Read more

Latest News

Read More

Wellbeing pays: the ROI HR can’t ignore

9 October 2025

Skills

7 October 2025

How to build a skills-based strategy

A key challenge for organisations looking at their skills strategy is getting their job data under control. Discover how creating a single source of truth...

Artificial Intelligence, Globalisation

7 October 2025

Talent strategies for business expansion and growth

Global Expansion 2025: Powerful Talent Management Strategies for a Diverse and AI-Driven Workforce....

Newsletter

Receive the latest HR news and strategic content

Please note, as per the GDPR Legislation, we need to ensure you are ‘Opted In’ to receive updates from ‘theHRDIRECTOR’. We will NEVER sell, rent, share or give away your data to third parties. We only use it to send information about our products and updates within the HR space To see our Privacy Policy – click here

Latest HR Jobs

London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine – Human ResourcesSalary: £39,432 to £45,097 per annum (pro-rata) inclusive

Harper Adams University – Human ResourcesSalary: £46,049 to £50,253 per annum. Grade 10

University of Cambridge – Department of Clinical NeurosciencesSalary: £27,319 to £31,236

Royal Conservatoire of ScotlandSalary: £52,074 to £58,611

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE

Read the latest digital issue of theHRDIRECTOR for FREE